A piece of light, flexible card - try the boxes of loosely packed products such as cereal, pasta, detergent powders etc. It should be around 400gsm, which is 3-4 times the weight of standard printer paper. If you can't find any around the house you can simple buy a piece of card at your local art, stationary or office supplies store.
Print out your boomerang template and cut it out. This template should have opened in a new tab during player selection, but if you've lost it, click here to go back.
Place your boomerang on a flat surface to check on which side the tips of the wings curve upwards slightly, then label the side facing up as the top. The process of cutting the boomerang out should have already given the wings a slight curve, lifting the tips up about 2-3mm, but you may need to accentuate it by gently bending the wings up a bit further.